Tagged with "miconception"
Pickup Power: The Ohm Misconception Tags: ohm ohms miconception power

 

Whenever we buy guitar pickups, one of the first things we look at is the K-ohm (kilo-ohm) rating.  The general belief is that the higher the K rating, the more "powerful" (louder) the pickup.   And to an extent, that is true.

However, measuring pickups strictly by ohms is a "layman's figure" the guitar industry uses to make general power ratings easier to understand.   The reality of it is that ohms have little to do with the actual power (volume) potential of a pickup.  There is a good reason for this:  ohms is not a measure of electric flow; is it a measure of electric impedence-- the resistance of the device to the flow of electricity.

Why then are ohms used as a pickup rating?  Because in general, ohms refer to how much copper is in the pickup coil.  The widespread belief is that the more copper wire, the more volume.  However, this belief is not correct.

Yes, in general, all things equal, given the same coil shape and the same wire thickness and consistency-- the higher the ohm rating the more powerful the pickup.   Mellow guitar pickups often have ohm ratings between 4.5K and 6K.   Humbuckers often run 7K to 9K+.  "Hot" pickups (ie heavy metal) sometimes hit 16K or more.  

But the reality is this:   a lot more is involved in making a guitar pickup than wrapping a wire a certain number of times around a magnet (a typical guitar "coil").  There are many variables involved.  That is why the field of guitar pickups is so complex and competitive, with everyone claiming to have a "special" pickup.   Those variables are why pickups sound different from one another.   If all that was involved was wrapping a specific number of coils around a magnet... all pickups would sound the same, the only difference being the number of wraps involved.

 

IS THE OHM / POWER RATING ACCURATE?

In a word, no.  This is proved if you wind thousands of hair-thin wire coils around a piece of cardboard-- no other metal or magnet involved-- and then take an ohm reading on those coils.  You will get near or even exactly the same ohm reading as if you wrapped them around a magnet.   

Ohms is a measurement not of electrons or the energy they generate, but the resistance in the wire to the movement of energy.  So how can it possibly rate power (ie, volume)?

In designing pickups we find that the diameter of the wire used, the tension in the wire, the way the coils are wrapped, the type and strength of magnet used, relationship of the wire to that magnet, polarity of the magnet, distance of the magnetic field from the strings and many other things are involved in creating a good guitar pickup.    Yes, if you're sporting a 17K pickup you are going to get some serious power and probably a lot of natural distortion in the process.   If you buy a 4.5K pickup it's almost certainly intended for clean, mellow blues and smooth jazz.   But as you've read here, it's just a generalization.  The best way to judge pickup sound and power is by ear.

It is because of these things that I built almost 200 FlatCats before I settled on the final design that produces its uniquely awesome sound and volume.

 

HOW ARE FLATCATS DIFFERENT?

FlatCats are very thin, which means they logically can't contain as many coil wraps as a standard large humbucker pickup.  It stands to reason the ohm rating is also going to be considerably lower.  How then, does a FlatCat produce its amazing volume and unusually rich and robust sound?

 

With most guitar pickups, the majority of the pickup sits inside the body, about an inch underneath the strings.  This is where the magnets are located and where the coils are located.  The magnetic field is usually carried up through pins to the vacinity of the strings.  That is why the magnets and coils have to be so large-- to carry that far.  

The FlatCat is different.  The entire pickup sits directly under the strings.  Nothing is stuck inside the guitar body or removed from the strings.   This allows the FlatCat to pick up every bit of energy, every nuance of sound from the strings. 

As a result, a FlatCat with a lower "ohm" rating produces as much "power" (volume and tone) as a full-size humbucker.  In fact a FlatCat can pick up some sounds a standard humbucker may miss, simply due to proximity to the strings and the way the FlatCat is designed internally.  The result is so unique, awesome and rich in tone that I use FlatCats on my personal guitars

 

ARE HIGH-OHM FLATCATS POSSIBLE?

In research and development phase, by using special types of wire and specific techniques I was able to create FlatCat pickups rating in excess of 10K ohms.  That is the equivalent of a "hot" humbucker pickup.   However in testing it was discovered that this was actually too much for the FlatCat design.  That close to the strings it created such a significant power flow that sound actually distorted and was too much for standard guitar amps. 

In short:  it is possible to have too much power on a pickup.  That's what happened when I pushed FlatCat design to its limits-- and convinced me to bring it back down to a more sensible and pleasantly-audible range.  For those who wish extreme heavy-metal overdrive, effects pedals are used even with standard pickups.  FlatCat works with those as well.

 

SOUND IS SUBJECTIVE

It's difficult to create a scientific measurement of "wonderful sound", because people's ears and tastes differ.   What sounds good to one person will sound not so good to another. 

Subjective sound is why in guitar, amp and pickup reviews one person will rave about a product while another will say it's the worst they've ever heard.     That's why there are so many different kinds of guitars, pickups and amps on the market.   Each offers a specific sound to appeal to different people.

FlatCat™ Pickups are designed to appeal to a wide variety of guitar playing styles and listening preferences.  Depending on your playing style, volume settings and the amp you use, FlatCat sound can range from smooth and mellow to "rock out".   FlatCat is a very versatile pickup that is enjoyed by musicians world wide.  All you need to do is read the reviews on Etsy to confirm that this is a fantastic pickup-- and that measurement of power by ohms is an industry-fostered misconception.  True pickup power is measured not by resistance in an electrical line, but by resulting volume and rich sound.  The FlatCat definitely produces the quality sound guitarists look for in a high-level pickup-- and does so at a very reasonable price.

https://Etsy.com/shop/Wishbringer

 

--o--

 

RSS

This website is powered by Spruz